Search
Search

Medicare

Health Hippo: Medicare

Health Hippo: Medicare

US CODE || CFR || CASES || REPORTS || CONGRESSIONAL RECORD || BILLS || FEDERAL REGISTER

Sleep and watchfulness, both of them, when immoderate, constitute disease.

The Medicare program was signed into law on July 30, 1965 by President Lyndon B. Johnson to provide health insurance for the elderly and disabled. Medicare’s early days were within the Social Security Administration, until it was combined with Medicaid into one agency under the Department of Health and Human Services in 1977. Medicare spending currently accounts for more than 15% of the federal budget, but is expected to exceed 1 trillion dollars and 20% of the budget in the next decade.

The Medicare Modernization Act (MMA), was signed into law on December 8, 2003. The MMA added prescription drug benefits to Medicare, revamped the managed care program, added important rural health protections and strengthened the program through cost containment and fraud and abuse provisions. The program is currently divided into four parts: Part A (hospital insurance), Part B (outpatient services and medical supplies/equipment), Part C (managed care), and Part D (prescription drugs).


U.S. Code

  • Protecting Access to Medicare Act of 2014 The 2014 “doc fix”. Includes another short-term fix to the SGR, as well as provisions with significant impact on providers and suppliers, including: clinical laboratories, skilled nursing facilities, hospitals, community mental health centers and dialysis providers. The law extends the current moratorium on RAC audits of hospital inpatient stays through March 31, 2015.
  • Affordable Care Act: Medicare Provisions.
    • Sec. 3401. Revision of certain market basket updates and incorporation of productivity improvements into market basket updates that do not already incorporate such improvements.
    • Sec. 3402. Temporary adjustment to the calculation of part B premiums.
    • Sec. 3403. Independent Medicare Advisory Board.
    • Sec. 4104. Removal of barriers to preventive services in Medicare.
    • Sec. 4103. Medicare coverage of annual wellness visit providing a personalized prevention plan.
    • Sec. 4105. Evidence-based coverage of preventive services in Medicare.
    • Sec. 10307. Improvements to the Medicare shared savings program.
    • Sec. 10320. Expansion of the scope of, and additional improvements to, the Independent Medicare Advisory Board.
    • Sec. 10323. Medicare coverage for individuals exposed to environmental health hazards.
    • Sec. 10330. Modernizing computer and data systems of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid services to support improvements in care delivery.
    • Sec. 10402. Amendments to subtitle B.
      • Preventive physical examination
  • Balanced Budget
    Act

    • Sec. 4103 Prostate cancer screening tests.
    • Sec. 4104 Coverage of colorectal screening.
    • Sec. 4105 Diabetes self-management benefits.
    • Sec. 4106 Standardization of medicare coverage of bone mass measurements.
    • Sec. 4108 Study on preventive and enhanced benefits.
    • Sec. 4631 Permanent extension and revision of certain secondary payer
      provisions.

    • Sec. 4632 Clarification of time and filing limitations.
    • Sec. 4633 Permitting recovery against third party administrators.
    • Sec. 4641 Placement of advance directive in medical record.
    • Sec. 4642 Increased certification period for certain organ procurement
      organizations.

    • Sec. 4643 Office of the Chief Actuary in the Health Care Financing
      Administration.

    • Sec. 4644 Conforming amendments to comply with congressional review of
      agency rulemaking.

  • 42 USC CHAPTER 7
    SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS

    • Subchapter II FEDERAL OLD-AGE, SURVIVORS, AND DISABILITY INSURANCE BENEFITS
      • 42 USC Sec. 405. Evidence, procedure, and certification for payments.
      • 42 USC Sec. 426. Entitlement to hospital insurance benefits.
      • 42 USC Sec. 426a. Transitional provision of eligibility of uninsured individuals for hospital insurance benefits.
    • Subchapter XVIII HEALTH INSURANCE FOR AGED AND DISABLED
      • Part A Hospital Insurance Benefits for Aged and Disabled (1395c–1395i5)
      • Part B Supplementary Medical Insurance Benefits for Aged and Disabled (1395j–1395w5)
      • Part C Medicare Choice Program (1395w21–1395w29)
      • Part D Voluntary Prescription Drug Benefit Program (1395w101–1395w154)
      • Part E Miscellaneous Provisions (1395x–1395kkk1)
      • Sec. 1395 Prohibition against any Federal interference
      • Sec. 1395a Free choice by patient guaranteed
      • Sec. 1395b Option to individuals to obtain other health insurance protection
      • Sec. 1395b-1 Incentives for economy while maintaining or improving quality in provision of health services
      • Sec. 1395b-2 Notice of medicare benefits; medicare and medigap information
      • Sec. 1395b-3 Health insurance advisory service for medicare beneficiaries
      • Sec. 1395b-4 Health insurance information, counseling, and assistance grants
      • Sec. 1395b-5 Beneficiary incentive programs
      • Sec. 1395b-6 Medicare Payment Advisory Commission
      • Sec. 1395b-7 Explanation of medicare benefits
      • Sec. 1395b-8 Chronic care improvement
      • Sec. 1395b-9 Provisions relating to administration
      • Sec. 1395b-10 Addressing health care disparities


Code of Federal
Regulations

  • 42 CFR CHAPTER IV, SUBCHAPTER B MEDICARE PROGRAM
    • PART 405 FEDERAL HEALTH INSURANCE FOR THE AGED AND DISABLED (405.201 – 405.2472)
      • SUBPART A [Reserved]
      • SUBPART B Medical Services Coverage Decisions
        That Relate to Health Care Technology (405.201 – 405.215)

        • Sec. 405.201 Scope of subpart and
          definitions.
        • Sec. 405.203 FDA categorization of
          investigational devices.
        • Sec. 405.205 Coverage of
          a non-experimental/investigational (Category B) device.
        • Sec. 405.207 Services related to a noncovered device.
        • Sec. 405.209 Payment for a
          non-experimental/investigational (Category B) device.
        • Sec. 405.211 Procedures for Medicare contractors in
          making coverage decisions for a non-experimental/investigational (Category B) device.
        • Sec. 405.213 Re-evaluation of a device categorization.
        • Sec. 405.215 Confidential commercial and trade
          secret information.
      • SUBPART C
        Suspension of Payment, Recovery of Overpayments, and Repayment of Scholarships and Loans (405.301 – 405.380)
      • SUBPART D Private Contracts (405.400 –
        405.455)
      • SUBPART E Criteria for Determining Reasonable Charges (405.500 – 405.535)
      • SUBPART F-G [Reserved]
      • SUBPART H Appeals Under the Medicare Part B
        Program (405.800 – 405.818)
      • SUBPART I
        Determinations, Redeterminations, Reconsiderations, and Appeals Under Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) (405.900 – 405.1140)

      • SUBPART J Expedited Determinations and
        Reconsiderations of Provider Service Terminations, and Procedures for Inpatient Hospital Discharges (405.1200 –
        405.1208)

      • SUBPART K-Q [Reserved]
      • SUBPART R Provider Reimbursement
        Determinations and Appeals (405.1801 – 405.1889)
      • SUBPART S-T [Reserved]
      • SUBPART U Conditions for Coverage of
        Suppliers of End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) Services (405.2100-405.2101 – 405.2131-405.2184)
      • SUBPART V-W [Reserved]
      • SUBPART
        X
        Rural Health Clinic and Federally Qualified Health Center Services (405.2400 – 405.2472)

    • PART 406 HOSPITAL INSURANCE ELIGIBILITY AND
      ENTITLEMENT (406.1 – 406.52)

      • SUBPART A General Provisions (406.1 – 406.7)
      • SUBPART B Hospital Insurance Without Monthly Premiums (406.10 – 406.15)
        • Sec. 406.10 Individual age 65 or over who is entitled to social security or railroad retirement benefits, or who is eligible for social security benefits.
        • Sec. 406.11 Individual age 65 or over who is not eligible as a social security or railroad retirement benefits beneficiary, or on the basis of government employment.
        • Sec. 406.12 Individual under age 65 who is entitled to social security or railroad retirement disability benefits.
        • Sec. 406.13 Individual who has end-stage renal disease.
        • Sec. 406.15 Special provisions applicable to Medicare qualified government employment.
      • SUBPART C Premium Hospital Insurance (406.20 – 406.38)
        • Sec. 406.20 Basic requirements.
        • Sec. 406.21 Individual enrollment.
        • Sec. 406.22 Effect of month of enrollment on entitlement.
        • Sec. 406.24 Special enrollment period related to coverage under group health plans.
        • Sec. 406.25 Special enrollment period for volunteers outside the United States.
        • Sec. 406.26 Enrollment under State buy-in.
        • Sec. 406.28 End of entitlement.
        • Sec. 406.32 Monthly premiums.
        • Sec. 406.33 Determination of months to be counted for premium increase: Enrollment.
        • Sec. 406.34 Determination of months to be counted for premium increase: Reenrollment.
        • Sec. 406.38 Prejudice to enrollment rights because of Federal Government error.
      • SUBPART D Special Circumstances That Affect Entitlement to Hospital Insurance (406.50 – 406.52)
    • PART 407
      SUPPLEMENTARY MEDICAL INSURANCE (SMI) ENROLLMENT AND ENTITLEMENT (407.1 – 407.50)
    • PART 408 PREMIUMS FOR SUPPLEMENTARY MEDICAL INSURANCE
      (408.1 – 408.210)
    • PART 409 HOSPITAL INSURANCE
      BENEFITS (409.1 – 409.102)

      • SUBPART A Hospital Insurance
        Benefits: General Provisions (409.1 – 409.5)
      • SUBPART B Inpatient Hospital Services and
        Inpatient Critical Access Hospital Services (409.10 – 409.18)
      • SUBPART C Posthospital SNF Care (409.20 –
        409.27)
      • SUBPART D Requirements for
        Coverage of Posthospital SNF Care (409.30 – 409.36)

      • SUBPART E Home Health Services Under
        Hospital Insurance (409.40 – 409.50)

      • SUBPART F Scope of Hospital Insurance
        Benefits (409.60 – 409.68)
      • SUBPART G
        Hospital Insurance Deductibles and Coinsurance (409.80 – 409.89)
      • SUBPART H Payment of Hospital Insurance
        Benefits (409.100 – 409.102)
    • PART 410 SUPPLEMENTARY MEDICAL INSURANCE (SMI)
      BENEFITS (410.1 – 410.175)
    • PART 411 EXCLUSIONS
      FROM MEDICARE AND LIMITATIONS ON MEDICARE PAYMENT (411.1 – 411.408)

      • SUBPART A General Exclusions and
        Exclusion of Particular Services (411.1 – 411.15)

        • Sec. 411.15 Particular services excluded from coverage.
    • PART 412 PROSPECTIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS FOR
      INPATIENT HOSPITAL SERVICES (412.1 – 412.632)
    • PART
      413
      PRINCIPLES OF REASONABLE COST REIMBURSEMENT; PAYMENT FOR END-STAGE RENAL DISEASE SERVICES; OPTIONAL
      PROSPECTIVELY DETERMINED PAYMENT RATES FOR SKILLED NURSING FACILITIES (413.1 – 413.355)
    • PART 414 PAYMENT FOR PART B MEDICAL AND OTHER HEALTH
      SERVICES (414.1 – 414.1105)

      • SUBPART A General Provisions
        (414.1 – 414.4)
      • SUBPART B Physicians
        and Other Practitioners (414.20 – 414.92)
      • SUBPART C Fee Schedules for Parenteral and
        Enteral Nutrition (PEN) Nutrients, Equipment and Supplies (414.100 – 414.104)
      • SUBPART D Payment for Durable Medical
        Equipment and Prosthetic and Orthotic Devices (414.200 – 414.232)
      • SUBPART E Determination of Reasonable Charges
        Under the ESRD Program (414.300 – 414.335)
      • SUBPART F Competitive Bidding for Certain
        Durable Medical Equipment, Prosthetics, Orthotics, and Supplies (DMEPOS) (414.400 – 414.426)
      • SUBPART G Payment for New Clinical Diagnostic
        Laboratory Tests (414.500 – 414.510)
      • SUBPART H Fee Schedule for Ambulance Services
        (414.601 – 414.625)
      • SUBPART I Payment
        for Drugs and Biologicals (414.701 – 414.707)
      • SUBPART J Submission of Manufacturer’s
        Average Sales Price Data (414.800 – 414.806)
      • SUBPART K Payment for Drugs and Biologicals
        Under Part B (414.900 – 414.930)
      • SUBPART
        L
        Supplying and Dispensing Fees (414.1000 – 414.1001)
      • SUBPART M Payment for Comprehensive
        Outpatient Rehabilitation Facility (CORF) Services (414.1100 – 414.1105)
    • PART 415 SERVICES FURNISHED BY PHYSICIANS IN
      PROVIDERS, SUPERVISING PHYSICIANS IN TEACHING SETTINGS, AND RESIDENTS IN CERTAIN SETTINGS (415.1 – 415.208)
    • PART 416 AMBULATORY SURGICAL SERVICES (416.1 – 416.200)
    • PART 417 HEALTH MAINTENANCE ORGANIZATIONS,
      COMPETITIVE MEDICAL PLANS, AND HEALTH CARE PREPAYMENT PLANS (417.1 – 417.940)
    • PART 418 HOSPICE CARE (418.1 – 418.405)
      • SUBPART A General Provision and
        Definitions (418.1 – 418.3)
      • SUBPART B
        Eligibility, Election and Duration of Benefits (418.20 – 418.30)
      • SUBPART C Conditions of Participation:
        Patient Care (418.52 – 418.78)
      • SUBPART
        D
        Conditions of participation: Organizational Environment (418.100 – 418.116)
      • SUBPART E
        [Reserved]
      • SUBPART F Covered Services
        (418.200 – 418.205)
      • SUBPART G Payment
        for Hospice Care (418.301 – 418.311)
      • SUBPART H Coinsurance (418.400 –
        418.405)
    • PART 419 PROSPECTIVE PAYMENT SYSTEM FOR HOSPITAL
      OUTPATIENT DEPARTMENT SERVICES (419.1 – 419.70)
    • PART
      420
      PROGRAM INTEGRITY: MEDICARE (420.1 – 420.410)

      • SUBPART A General Provisions
        (420.1 – 420.3)
      • SUBPART B [Reserved]
      • SUBPART C Disclosure of Ownership and Control
        Information (420.200 – 420.206)
      • SUBPART
        D
        Access to Books, Documents, and Records of Subcontractors (420.300 – 420.304)
      • SUBPART E Rewards for Information Relating to
        Medicare Fraud and Abuse, and Establishment of a Program to Collect Suggestions for Improving Medicare Program
        Efficiency and to Reward Suggesters for Monetary Savings (420.400 – 420.410)
    • PART 421 MEDICARE CONTRACTING (421.1 – 421.505)
    • PART 422 MEDICARE ADVANTAGE PROGRAM (422.1 –
      422.2276)

      • SUBPART A General Provisions
        (422.1 – 422.6)
      • SUBPART B Eligibility,
        Election, and Enrollment (422.50 – 422.74)
      • SUBPART C Benefits and Beneficiary
        Protections (422.100 – 422.133)
      • SUBPART
        D
        Quality Improvement (422.152 – 422.158)
      • SUBPART E Relationships With Providers
        (422.200 – 422.220)
      • SUBPART F
        Submission of Bids, Premiums, and Related Information and Plan Approval (422.250 – 422.270)
      • SUBPART G Payments to Medicare Advantage
        Organizations (422.300 – 422.324)
      • SUBPART
        H
        Provider-Sponsored Organizations (422.350 – 422.390)
      • SUBPART I Organization Compliance With State
        Law and Preemption by Federal Law (422.400 – 422.404)
      • SUBPART J Special Rules for MA Regional Plans
        (422.451 – 422.458)
      • SUBPART K
        Application Procedures and Contracts for Medicare Advantage Organizations (422.500 – 422.527)
      • SUBPART L Effect of Change of Ownership or
        Leasing of Facilities During Term of Contract (422.550 – 422.553)
      • SUBPART M Grievances, Organization
        Determinations and Appeals (422.560 – 422.626)
      • SUBPART N Medicare Contract Determinations
        and Appeals (422.641 – 422.696)
      • SUBPART
        O
        Intermediate Sanctions (422.750 – 422.764)
      • SUBPART P [Reserved]
      • SUBPART T Appeal procedures for Civil Money
        Penalties (422.1000 – 422.1094)
      • SUBPART
        V
        Medicare Advantage Marketing Requirements (422.2260 – 422.2276)
    • PART 423 VOLUNTARY MEDICARE PRESCRIPTION DRUG
      BENEFIT (423.1 – 423.2345)

      • SUBPART A General Provisions
        (423.1 – 423.6)
      • SUBPART B Eligibility
        and Enrollment (423.30 – 423.56)
      • SUBPART
        C
        Benefits and Beneficiary Protections (423.100 – 423.136)
      • SUBPART D Cost Control and Quality
        Improvement Requirements (423.150 – 423.171)
      • SUBPART E [Reserved]
      • SUBPART F Submission of Bids and Monthly
        Beneficiary Premiums; Plan Approval (423.251 – 423.293)
      • SUBPART G Payments to Part D Plan Sponsors
        For Qualified Prescription Drug Coverage (423.301 – 423.350)
      • SUBPART H [Reserved]
      • SUBPART I Organization Compliance with State
        Law and Preemption by Federal Law (423.401 – 423.440)
      • SUBPART J Coordination of Part D Plans With
        Other Prescription Drug Coverage (423.452 – 423.466)
      • SUBPART K Application Procedures and
        Contracts with Part D plan sponsors (423.500 – 423.520)
      • SUBPART L Effect of Change of Ownership or
        Leasing of Facilities During Term of Contract (423.551 – 423.553)
      • SUBPART M Grievances, Coverage
        Determinations, Redeterminations, and Reconsiderations (423.558 – 423.638)
      • SUBPART N Medicare Contract Determinations
        and Appeals (423.641 – 423.668)
      • SUBPART
        O
        Intermediate Sanctions (423.750 – 423.764)
      • SUBPART P Premiums and Cost-Sharing Subsidies
        for Low-Income Individuals (423.771 – 423.800)
      • SUBPART Q Guaranteeing Access to a Choice of
        Coverage (Fallback Prescription Drug Plans) (423.851 – 423.875)
      • SUBPART R Payments to Sponsors of Retiree
        Prescription Drug Plans (423.880 – 423.894)
      • SUBPART S Special Rules for
        States-Eligibility Determinations for Subsidies and General Payment Provisions (423.900 – 423.910)
      • SUBPART T Appeal Procedures for Civil Money
        Penalties (423.1000 – 423.1094)
      • SUBPART
        U
        Reopening, ALJ Hearings, MAC review, and Judicial Review (423.1968 – 423.2140)
      • SUBPART V Part D Marketing Requirements
        (423.2260 – 423.2276)
      • SUBPART W
        Medicare Coverage Gap Discount Program (423.2300 – 423.2345)
    • PART 424 CONDITIONS FOR MEDICARE PAYMENT (424.1
      – 424.570)
    • PART 425 MEDICARE SHARED SAVINGS
      PROGRAM (425.10 – 425.810)
    • PART 426 REVIEW OF
      NATIONAL COVERAGE DETERMINATIONS AND LOCAL COVERAGE DETERMINATIONS (426.100 – 426.587)


Cases

    Entitlement

    • NCD 140.3: Transsexual Surgery (2014)(National Coverage Determination (NCD) denying Medicare coverage of all transsexual surgery as a treatment for transsexualism is not valid under the “reasonableness standard”)
    • In the Case of Y.H.
      (February 22, 2010) (the purported statements of an employee in the administrative office of a U.S. Post Office are
      insufficient, standing alone, to warrant equitable relief from a Part B premium surcharge for late enrollment in
      the Medicare Supplementary Medicare Insurance program).
    • In the Case of F.C. (October 21,
      2009) (current employment, for the purpose of enrolling in Medicare Part B during a special enrollment period, is
      when an individual is actively working as an employee or has a business relationship with an employer).
    • In the Case of J.B.K. (November
      18, 2009) (equitable relief from a premium penalty for delayed enrollment is not available due to non-action by a
      non-federal entity).
    • In the
      Case of J.J.K.
      (October 9, 2009) (the beneficiary is not entitled to withdrawal from Medicare Part A hospital
      insurance and be paid only monthly retirement benefits).
    • In the Case of D.B. (December
      15, 2009) (the beneficiary is not entitled to equitable relief as the evidence indicates the beneficiary chose not
      to enroll in Medicare Part B due to incorrect information she provided about her spouse’s group health insurance
      plan, not due to misrepresentation from the Social Security Administration).

    Secondary Payer

    • In the Case of E.M.P. (June
      28, 2011) (the Council orders three charges removed from the Medicare lien assessed against the appellant, noting
      that the ICD identifies a condition while the HCPCS identifies a treatment for that condition).
    • In the Case of F.G.
      (October 20, 2010) (A settling party must consider Medicare’s right of recovery when negotiating a settlement
      amount).
    • In the Case of
      M.B.C.
      (March 19, 2010) (the beneficiary is not liable for Medicare payments for treatment associated with a
      lower back injury under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act as the evidence of record shows these treatments are
      unrelated to the cervical spine injuries that resulted in a workers’ compensation settlement).
    • In the Case of W.G. (November
      10, 2009) (the beneficiary is required to repay the conditional payments made on her behalf for medical treatment
      following an automobile accident as all medical expenses are presumptively included in a settlement amount).
    • In the Case of A.H. (November 6,
      2009) (Medicare is entitled to recover from settlement proceeds without regard to how the settlement agreement
      stipulates disbursement should be made, even if the parties agreed that a portion of the settlement proceeds are
      unrelated to the accident or injury).

    Overpayment

    • In the Case of Discount
      Diabetic
      (June 29, 2012) (The Council determined that pursuant to section 1870(b) of the Act, the appellant is
      waived from recovery of the overpayment).
    • In the Case of Steven Kalter,
      M.D.
      (August 11, 2011) (a contractor only needs to account for underpayments that have been uncovered as the
      result of an audit when calculating an overpayment, it need not actively pursue underpayments).
    • In the Case of
      Charles Stockwell, O.D.
      (February 14, 2011) (Prior to applying the waiver provisions of sections 1879 and 1870,
      the ALJ should have first determined whether services provided to the beneficiaries in each case met the coverage
      provisions of the Act).
    • In the Case of
      The Endocrine Clinic, P.C.
      (November 10, 2010) (While the appellant contends that the Medicare contractor erred
      in recalculating Medicare’s overpayment following the ALJ’s decision, the regulations contemplate that an ALJ’s
      decision is not final for the purposes of determining the amount of payment due).
    • In the Case of
      Excel Diagnostics, Ltd.
      (October 14, 2010) (Medicare payment is appropriate for diagnostic doses of Indium-111
      administered to beneficiaries during a clinical trial but payment is denied for additional therapeutic doses).
    • In the Case of
      Home Care 4 U, Inc.
      (May 25, 2010) (overpayment cannot be sustained as a matter of due process when the PSC has
      failed to provide evidence in the record to support its finding that the treating physician did not sign the plans
      of care at issue).
    • In the Case of
      American Health Network of Indiana, LLC, and Adam D. Perler, D.P.M.
      (February 25, 2010) (the ALJ erred in
      addressing the issues of coverage and liability when the Council had addressed these issues prior to remanding the
      case back to the ALJ to address the sole issue of whether the appellant was “without fault” under the provisions of
      section 1870(b) of the Act).
    • In the Case of KGV
      Easy Leasing Corporation
      (February 22, 2010) (beneficiary information submitted that does not indicate that the
      referring physician was the treating physician, that the treating physician used results from diagnostic tests in
      managing the patient, or present a complete clinical picture of the medical conditions that presumptively warranted
      the testing fails to demonstrate that the claims were medically reasonable and necessary for the purposes of
      Medicare coverage).
    • In the Case
      of Mid South Psychiatric Associates
      (December 23, 2009) (the fact that the appellant filed individual requests
      for ALJ hearing, rather than discussing the basis for re-adjudicating sampled claims in one submission, does not
      require that the appellant seek aggregation of those claims in order to exercise appeal rights of an extrapolated
      overpayment).
    • In the Case of
      Lakeside Foot Clinic
      (October 15, 2009) (in a case arising from an overpayment based on statistical sampling,
      an appellant must be given an opportunity to challenge both the findings on the individual services reviewed in the
      sample and the sampling methodology and extrapolation).
    • In the Case of Transyd
      Enterprises, LLC
      (September 15, 2009) (the burden is on the appellant to prove the statistical sampling
      methodology was invalid and not on the contractor to establish that it chose the most precise methodology).
    • In the Case of Whidbey
      General Hospital
      (December 3, 2007) (the appellant had sufficient notice at the time the provider billed and
      received payment for the supplied drugs to identify the overpayments received and the recovery of the overpayment
      is not waived under section 1870(b) of the Social Security Act).
    • In the Case of
      Quality Home Health Services, Inc.
      (September 14, 2009) (the appellant does not challenge the validity of the
      statistical sample or the extrapolation methodology but instead focuses the appellate arguments on the individual
      claims for home health services).
    • In the Case of Lance E.
      Daniel, O.D.
      (December 3, 2009) (if, as in this case, some of the individual sample claims were wrongly denied,
      the overpayment is re-extrapolated based on the remaining denied claims in the sample).
    • In the Case of
      Comprehensive Decubitus Therapy
      (March 13, 2009) (the supplier was without fault in creating an overpayment for
      surgical dressing based on its efforts to verify the beneficiary’s coverage status in advance of providing the
      items).

    Statistical Sampling

    • In the Case of Robert D.
      Lesser, M.D. & Associates
      (Dec. 7, 2011) (The ALJ erred by invalidating the statistical sample in this case and
      by waiving the appellant’s liability for all overpayments during the applicable time period).
    • In the Case of Meridian
      Laboratory Corporation
      (June 24, 2011) (the appellant is obligated to provide supporting documentation to
      establish the medical necessity of the sampled claims).
    • In the Case of John Sanders,
      M.D.
      (May 12, 2011) (the Council determines that the sampling was sufficiently flawed to preclude calculation
      of an overpayment by extrapolation and the appellant is financially liable only for the overpayments on the
      individual claims in the sample).
    • In the Case of Michael King,
      M.D. and Kinston Medical Specialists, P.A.
      (May 10, 2011) (the Council need not find that CMS or its contractor
      undertook statistical sampling and extrapolation based on the most precise methodology that might be devised in
      order to uphold an overpayment extrapolation but instead the test is whether the methodology is statistically
      valid).
    • In
      the Case of Global Home Care, Inc.
      (January 11, 2011) (When the record does not contain complete documentation
      to recreate the sampling frame, a provider does not have the information and data necessary to mount a due process
      challenge to the statistical validity of the sample).
    • In the Case of
      Podiatric Medical Associates
      (June 22, 2010) (appellant was deprived of its ability to review the extrapolation
      in question when PSC failed to provide pertinent audit-related information).
    • In the Case of Maxxim
      Care, EMS
      (February 25, 2010) (CMS or its contractor must use a statistically valid methodology for sampling
      and extrapolation, not necessarily the most precise methodology that might be devised).
    • In the Case of Idaho
      Falls Chiropractic Clinic, P.L.L.C.
      (February 22, 2010) (in a probe review, contractors collect overpayments
      only on claims that are actually reviewed and may not extrapolate the overpayment to a universe of claims pursuant
      to the MPIM).

    Hearings and Appeals Procedures

    • In the Case of King’s Daughter
      Medical Center
      (June 26, 2012) (The Council found that the regulation on which CMS relied in its referral
      memorandum does not apply in this case and that the ALJ did not err in affording greater weight to the admitting
      physician’s decision for inpatient admission).
    • In the Case of Spokane
      Washington Hospital Company
      (June 19, 2012) (The Council declined to review the ALJ’s decision because,
      contrary to CMS’s assertion, there were no errors of law material to the outcome of the case).
    • In the Case of Nizhoni Health
      Systems
      (June 1, 2012) (The Council remanded because the ALJ failed to notify the provider of the home health
      services at issue of the proceedings at the ALJ level and provide it with an opportunity to participate).
    • In the Case of Eagle Air
      Medical Corporation
      (April 12, 2012) (remanding where the beneficiary did not receive notice of the appeals
      proceeding that took place after the QIC’s review).
    • In the Case of Cashflow
      Solutions, Inc.
      (April 6, 2012) (adding claims at the ALJ level that have not been adjudicated at lower appeals
      levels is prohibited).
    • In the Case of American Home
      Podiatry
      (May 20, 2011) (an appellant may not seek a subpoena in order to shift the burden of proof to the
      contractor).
    • In the
      Case of A.L.
      (January 21, 2011) (The beneficiary died after filing a request for hearing before an ALJ. The
      appellant has not demonstrated that she is authorized to act on behalf of a proper party, or otherwise has any
      interest as a substitute party).
    • In the case of C.C. (July
      2, 2010) (the unrepresented beneficiary filed a single request for hearing before the ALJ listing five dates of
      services originally at issue and the record demonstrates it was reasonable for the beneficiary to believe the all
      the dates of service at issue would be treated as one aggregated appeal).
    • In the Case of
      International Rehab. Sciences
      (April 8, 2009) (if a request for claims to be aggregated for an ALJ hearing is
      based on common issues of law and fact, the claims must arise from similar, but not necessarily identical, fact
      patterns).
    • In the
      Case of Philip B. Khourty, M.D.
      (October 2, 2009) (the appellant submitted evidence of a serious illness in his immediate family as good cause for the untimely filing of his request for hearing before an ALJ).
    • In the Case of
      Health & Oncology, Inc.
      (September 21, 2009) (the appellant had good cause for submitting new evidence after
      the reconsideration by the qualified independent contractor (QIC) as the QIC’s decision identified a new issue for
      the basis of the denial).
    • In the Case of Robert
      Markman, M.D.
      (October 21, 2009) (the ALJ did not abuse his discretion in denying the appellant’s request for
      subpoenas).
    • In the Case of
      Breton L. Morgan, M.D.
      (November 5, 2009) (an ALJ must identify in a meaningful way the documentation which
      will be excluded from the record).
    • In the Case of John
      Handron, Ph.D.
      (May 22, 2008) (while section 504 of the Equal Access to Justice Act allows for fees and
      expenses for administrative proceedings conducted before an ALJ in connection with adversarial Medicare
      proceedings, the position of the United States must be represented at the ALJ hearing by counsel or otherwise to
      qualify for payment of attorney fees).
    • In the Case of General
      Medicine, P.C.
      (September 6, 2007) (if an ALJ fails to adjudicate claims for which perfected requests for
      hearing were filed within the 90-day deadline, an appellant may request the claim be escalated to the Council;
      after receiving the request for escalation, the ALJ has five days to adjudicate the claims, if the ALJ is unable to
      adjudicate the claims, the appellant must then file a request for escalation with the Council to review the
      reconsideration decision(s); an appellant has no right to request escalation to the Council when it waived, in
      writing, the ALJ’s adjudication deadline).

    IRMAA (Medicare Part B Premium)

    • In the Case of R.F. (October 8,
      2009) (gambling winnings are included in the calculation of a modified adjusted gross income but gambling losses
      are not subtracted).


Reports


Uncle Sam

Health Hippo ©1996-present
Contact Information